AI traffic, specifically military

strykerpsg

strykerpsg

SOH-CM-2023
Happy holidays all!

While anxiously awaiting the forthcoming Just Flight Traffic addition for MSFS, I have noticed I never see any traffic at military specific airfields. Heck, there's not even any commercial or general aviation at any military airfields. Is this common to any that fly military airfields that haven't been modified by freeware?

I have seen MAIW advertising some future release packs too, so I know it's all in the works, just anxious to hear other's experiences too.

Just hoping that maybe there's a setting I have overlooked with regards to AI traffic.

Thanks.
 
For all i know when it comes to airplanes AI traffic is broken.

I just see cars, buses and trucks driving by at any airport, no planes.. I certainly used tp see AI planes take-off and land (i don't think i ever saw a militairy AI plane though..) but suddenly that stopped. Not sure after which update our sky became such an empty place. I guess we just have to wait for Microsobo to give our virtual colleagues take-off clearance again. I always ran MAIW as well. Absolutely brilliant. Not sure anymore if it was MAIW but i never stopped trying until i was obliged to line up after a Spitfire or Mustang, or wait for a DC-6 to land. Sure hope we get a chance for that to happen in MSFS some day too. :)
 
Javis said:
For all i know when it comes to airplanes AI traffic is broken.

I just see cars, buses and trucks driving by at any airport, no planes.. I certainly used tp see AI planes take-off and land (i don't think i ever saw a militairy AI plane though..) but suddenly that stopped. Not sure after which update our sky became such an empty place. I guess we just have to wait for Microsobo to give our virtual colleagues take-off clearance again. I always ran MAIW as well. Absolutely brilliant. Not sure anymore if it was MAIW but i never stopped trying until i was obliged to line up after a Spitfire or Mustang, or wait for a DC-6 to land. Sure hope we get a chance for that to happen in MSFS some day too. :)
Click to expand...

Thank you for confirming I had seen AI at civil fields before and now I don't either.

Hoping live AI for military become part of the scenery this upcoming year.
 
Unfortunately our good friends at Asobo broke the AI system in the newest update for the sim. I doubt that this was their intention, more so an unfortunate consequence of all the other things they added. A casualty of progress I suppose.

Now here's the real rub. The guys still active at MAIW (bless them!) had been making very good progress over the past year or so on implementing military AI traffic into this sim. You can still see preview shots at the website. There were two new models ready to go, AI F-35A/B/C and AI F-15E and a few more in the works including a KC-135R and A-10C that he was working on as well. The beta testing was quite far along and the results looked really promising.

Then it all came crashing down with the new sim update. All that time, work, testing and effort for.......... well nothing apparently for now and who knows when?? Imagine spending over a year testing, tweaking, trying things, developing and getting something ready to be released all for it to just blow up with the newest sim update.

You can imagine the frustration and anger this has generated. To the point that I think the boys are just going to go back and concentrate on P3d and FSX for the foreseeable future. At this point, no one knows when or if Asobo will get serious about AI traffic and there's no point in even trying to develop anything for MSFS until such time that they finally quit changing things.

What a cluster....
 
This is quite annoying
That's why I didn't delete P3D
Unfortunately, taxiing between the static scenery of MSFS is quite boring
 
Thanks for the HU, Mike !

Bummer to hear that and quite worrying too...

Only thing we can do is think positive about it and expect Asobo to deal with it as top priority to fix, or atleast put it on the PLF (Priority List to Fix)

Fingers crossed (not put up minus one :playful:)
 
That's really disappointing news about MAIW in MSFS.

For the life of me I don't understand why the ASOBO pre-release testing does not pick up these things. Okay I understand that MAIW is not (yet) a regular developer for MSFS but as we know many of the mainstream commercial Devs are constantly being knocked back by these sim updates.

You would have thought that every change they make in each update is cross checked with at least the most regular and popular add-ons from the mainstream Devs.

From the outside it seems that the updates are introduced in total isolation without any co-ordination with the 3rd party world?
 
This problem with Asobo breaking things must get tiresome, especially for payware creators who have to go back and create fixes for something previously made through no fault of their own.
 
guzler said:
This problem with Asobo breaking things must get tiresome, especially for payware creators who have to go back and create fixes for something previously made through no fault of their own.
Click to expand...

I am tired of the constant updates the devlopers are forced to make, because of Asobo keeps breaking their own toy. I am having trouble keeping up with the emails informing me of a new update I should download and install.
 
Perhaps we should all go back to FSX, which provided a stable platform for so many years, allowing the evolution of all of our 3rd-party devs :)

Change is a necessary evil...we just need Asobo to be a little more professional about it...
 
collensr said:
That's really disappointing news about MAIW in MSFS.

For the life of me I don't understand why the ASOBO pre-release testing does not pick up these things. Okay I understand that MAIW is not (yet) a regular developer for MSFS but as we know many of the mainstream commercial Devs are constantly being knocked back by these sim updates.

You would have thought that every change they make in each update is cross checked with at least the most regular and popular add-ons from the mainstream Devs.

From the outside it seems that the updates are introduced in total isolation without any co-ordination with the 3rd party world?
Click to expand...

I just think AI traffic is so far down their list of priorities these days, we may never see a system like FSX or FS9 had in place. Especially if a few 3rd party devs set up a robust AI traffic addon at their own expense.
 
OT solution: One solution for Military aviation lovers (while not always welcomed, for some reason or other) is DCS. The AI is by and large very good, and can perform very complex flight plans. While, yes, you are limited to specific geographic areas, the expansion of those areas is growing quickly. The benefit is that you have mostly ALL the assets and major Air Bases modeled in a region. And you get ALL the payware models as AI assets. If MSFS really is so averse to creating an AI system, or is in a state of development where it's not stable enough for development of complex systems like that, it might be a good alternative for people looking to fill that niche until such time that MSFS can support it. Before anyone jumps on the "this isn't a DCS forum" bandwagon, I'm just throwing out an alternative. This thread isn't in the DCS forum so if I posted it there, no one here would see it. I'm not taking any position of "one sim is better than another". None of that is being implied. I'm just saying that everything being talked about previously can be done or had in DCS for modern and by and large WWII enthusiasts for AI stuff.

Watch the latest video released today for a peak at a lot of the available AI assets.

http://www.sim-outhouse.com/sohforums/showthread.php/129125-Dcs-2-8?p=1304609&viewfull=1#post1304609
 
Mach3DS said:
OT solution: One solution for Military aviation lovers (while not always welcomed, for some reason or other) is DCS. The AI is by and large very good, and can perform very complex flight plans. While, yes, you are limited to specific geographic areas, the expansion of those areas is growing quickly. The benefit is that you have mostly ALL the assets and major Air Bases modeled in a region. And you get ALL the payware models as AI assets. If MSFS really is so averse to creating an AI system, or is in a state of development where it's not stable enough for development of complex systems like that, it might be a good alternative for people looking to fill that niche until such time that MSFS can support it. Before anyone jumps on the "this isn't a DCS forum" bandwagon, I'm just throwing out an alternative. This thread isn't in the DCS forum so if I posted it there, no one here would see it. I'm not taking any position of "one sim is better than another". None of that is being implied. I'm just saying that everything being talked about previously can be done or had in DCS for modern and by and large WWII enthusiasts for AI stuff.

Watch the latest video released today for a peak at a lot of the available AI assets.

http://www.sim-outhouse.com/sohforums/showthread.php/129125-Dcs-2-8?p=1304609&viewfull=1#post1304609
Click to expand...

Agreed on the recommendation. I float between the two but DCS is very limited in both aircraft and terrain. While DCS is maturing with a campaign engine (WooHoo, finally!!) it's still a stark contrast in what MSFS offers. It too is very pretty to fly at all levels as well. I feel confident MSFS will mature enough for developers to finish their WIPs, such as JF Traffic due in the near future, along with MAIW.
 
AI Military traffic for me would supplement the civilian stuff, not be a major focus. I still enjoy flying pointy jets in MSFS, and that won't change, so it would be cool to have some traffic at military bases. I'm not sure Asobo is all onboard the AI train either. I suspect they don't want the sim bogged down with the lower frame rates it might entail, not to mention more headaches, they seem to have plenty already. Remember the legacy stuff and how they said they would support it? The updates have pretty much destroyed them.
 
Snurdley said:
AI Military traffic for me would supplement the civilian stuff, not be a major focus. I still enjoy flying pointy jets in MSFS, and that won't change, so it would be cool to have some traffic at military bases. I'm not sure Asobo is all onboard the AI train either. I suspect they don't want the sim bogged down with the lower frame rates it might entail, not to mention more headaches, they seem to have plenty already. Remember the legacy stuff and how they said they would support it? The updates have pretty much destroyed them.
Click to expand...

I agree mostly with this. For me, not just the incoming and outgoing AI military traffic, but nothing parked at all on any military base, anywhere. It just detracts from the immersion of being a part of a simulated world. Since I love flying more military add-ons currently, it just seems like an apocalyptic atmosphere, me and an empty world. This was always an attraction to the MAIW stuff in FSX, low poly counts, nice animations and just good interaction with military and civil airports.
 
Mach3DS said:
Here's the update you've probably been waiting for. Whole earth. Anyway. I'll keep it all back in the correct forum from here on out.

https://www.digitalcombatsimulator.com/en/news/newsletters/a6204cbc7d5df25e887acb434b2f8e1b/
Click to expand...

This is different thing, DCS hasnt AI (as default) traffc. The each default map is empty from the beginning, worse like in FSX, P3D or MSFS even. The glob as 3D doesnt mean that AI will cover the whole glob. Of course, editor is easy to create some of „missions” including AI but its not the same like in MSFS. Btw. dont wait for this whole the World, as I know ED it will be maybe not before second part of 2024 (or even 2025) so its a long trip for this still.
 
Yup. It's all true. But put a few minutes into a mission and you've got it always. You can even spawn aircraft and ground units from the menu if you want. But if MSFS doesn't have it at all right now...I guess you can just not have it at all or you can get it with a small investment of time. Either way, you can get it now to satisfy your itch. Or you can fly with nothing. Anyway. Just a suggestion. Take it or leave it. I'm enjoying it. If MSFS ever gets proper Military attention that will be great!
 
strykerpsg said:
I agree mostly with this. For me, not just the incoming and outgoing AI military traffic, but nothing parked at all on any military base, anywhere. It just detracts from the immersion of being a part of a simulated world. Since I love flying more military add-ons currently, it just seems like an apocalyptic atmosphere, me and an empty world. This was always an attraction to the MAIW stuff in FSX, low poly counts, nice animations and just good interaction with military and civil airports.
Click to expand...

Not meaning to hijack this thread which has a very valid point but I've been trying to address this with static planes and apron equipment in the WIP Beale that will hopefully be available from Blackbird Simulations sooner than later. AI is still hard to make in MSFS, hopefully again sooner than later.

Screenshot (628).jpgScreenshot (612).jpgScreenshot (600).jpgScreenshot (618).jpgScreenshot (622).jpg
 
Dimus said:
Not meaning to hijack this thread which has a very valid point but I've been trying to address this with static planes and apron equipment in the WIP Beale that will hopefully be available from Blackbird Simulations sooner than later. AI is still hard to make in MSFS, hopefully again sooner than later.

View attachment 89465View attachment 89466View attachment 89467View attachment 89468View attachment 89469
Click to expand...

Yes, yes, yes....for 2 reasons, knowing Blackbird is releasing an upcoming SR71 and another detailed military base. Love it.. Thanks for sharing Dimus. Looking forward to it, very much.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top