• There seems to be an up tick in Political commentary in recent months. Those of us who are long time members of the site we know that Political and Religious content has been banned for years. Nothing has changed. Please leave all political and religiours commentary out of the fourms.

    If you recently joined the forums you were not presented with this restriction in the terms of service. This was due to a conversion error when we went from vBulletin to Xenforo. We have updated our terms of service to reflect these corrections.

    Please note any post refering to a politicion will be considered political even if it is intended to be humor. Our experience is these topics have a way of dividing the forums and causing deep resentment amoung members. It is a poison to the community. We apprciate compliance with the rules.

    The Staff of SOH

  • Server side Maintenance is done. We still have an update to the forum software to run but that one will have to wait for a better time.

History and Details of the P-51D-5-NA (A Flight Sim Project)

Bomber_12th

SOH-CM-2025
I want to welcome everyone to another "history lesson" from your resident Mustang aficionado (putting it lightly). : ) I also want to spend some time introducing you to one of Warbirdsim’s up-coming products for FSX, the P-51D-5-NA. I hope you enjoy!


The Birth of the P-51D

Not all too unlike the original request for P-51 development, or the integration of the Rolls-Royce Merlin engine into the airframe, or even the genesis of the name itself -Mustang - the initial concept behind what would become the P-51D, the most known and recognized of the series of Mustang fighters, can be traced directly to Britain.

<o:p></o:p>
By early 1943, the British had figured out how to create a bubble or “teardrop” canopy, providing a clear 360-degree view all around, and began installing them to the latest mark Spitfires and Typhoons. The USAAF sent Col. Mark Bradley to <st1:country-region w:st="on">England</st1:country-region> in January of ’43, to “learn the workings of this new canopy and find a way to get them onto <st1:country-region w:st="on"><st1:place w:st="on">U.S.</st1:place></st1:country-region> fighters.” Upon return, Bradley immediately set forth to incorporate this new style of canopy design into <st1:country-region w:st="on"><st1:place w:st="on">U.S.</st1:place></st1:country-region> fighter production. The first USAAF fighter so tested was the Republic P-47.
<o:p></o:p>
Not wasting any time, P-51B-1, 43-12102 was selected off the North American Aviation assembly line, to be modified as a test aircraft for the new bubble canopy, and house-designated the NA-109. The new canopy provided almost complete unobstructed vision, with virtually no distortion from the free-blown glazing. This new canopy was mounted to rollers, connected via chain and pulley to a manual hand-crank assembly on the starboard side of the cockpit. In order to accommodate this new canopy, the rear fuselage had to be cut down. This modified P-51B took flight for the first time on November 17, 1943, under the control of famed NAA test pilot Bob Chilton.
<o:p></o:p>
The success of 43-12102 led NAA to modify P-51B-10-NA 43-106539 and 43-106540, under a new house-designation, NA-106. These aircraft would effectively become the first of the true line of P-51D’s, officially titled XP-51D, and later P-51D-NA. Beyond the canopy modifications, the aircraft’s wings were also modified, with the addition of six .50-in machine guns (rather than four, as on previous Mustangs). The new mounting setup for the machine guns also corrected the gun-jamming issues that plagued the P-51B’s and C’s.
<o:p></o:p>
The landing gear operation was also re-designed, and this led to an increase in the wing root chord. The angle of the main landing gear struts, the main landing gear doors, and the entire main gear wells were completely changed. Improvements were also made to the effectiveness and strength of the ailerons. The landing light was moved from the wing leading edge to inside the landing gear well.
<o:p></o:p>
The very first production P-51D’s, officially titled P-51D-5-NA’s, began to enter service in Europe in late May and early June, 1944, just in time for the D-Day invasion, and the events that followed. Some of the most all-time recognizable P-51D’s – “LouIV,” “Cripes A’ Mighty 3rd,” “Frenesi,” “Hurry Home Honey,” “Donald Duck,” “Flying Dutchman,” “Happy Jack’s Go Buggy,” and the 52nd FG “Marie” – were P-51D-5-NA’s.
<o:p></o:p>
By mid-late P-51D-5-NA production, a report that the tails of P-51B’s, C’s, and D’s were failing structurally due to violent snap-rolls, had to be addressed. North American engineered a fillet for the dorsal fin, which tapered up into the vertical stabilizer from the point of the production-break between the fuselage and tail assemblies. This fillet both added more structural strength, and also cut down on the violent effects of snap-rolling the aircraft. This fillet was first installed on the last few production P-51D-5-NA’s, and into P-51D-10-NA production. Through a technical order that was issued, kits were also sent to all P-51D-5-NA’s and early Mustangs already operating in the field. These fillets were of a slightly different construction-design than those fitted in production of later P-51D’s.
<o:p></o:p>
Now, to dig into some of the finer details of what made the P-51D-5-NA unique to any other D-model, I have compiled together a list of just some of the unique details that set it apart, and I hope to illustrate these points through screenshots of Warbirdsim’s up-coming P-51D-5-NA product. This is by far the most focused P-51D-5-NA ever designed for any flight simulator platform, and I hope to continue to provide more screenshots and information on the product, through updates posted to this thread, up until the point that the product is released in the coming days. All screenshots feature “work-in-progress”, thus-far.
 
P-51D-5-NA Exterior

First of all, I’d like to provide a detailed look at the exterior of the P-51D-5-NA.
<o:p> </o:p>
- The most obvious, defining feature of the P-51D-5-NA, is the lack of a dorsal fin fillet. The flight characteristics, as a result, were different when it came to yaw-stability, or the lack there of. This handling difference has been incorporated into the new flight dynamics for the Warbirdsim P-51D-5-NA. <o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- There was no oil radiator drain added until P-51D-10-NA production, so along the bottom of the lower cowling panel, there is no oil drain access door. There was also yet to be a fuel strainer access door added to the lower cowling panel, until late D-model production.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- The gun camera port was circular in form on the P-51D-5-NA, but on the P-51D-10-NA and later models, with the gun camera type changed, the gun camera port would became rectangular in form.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- A static ground wire below the tail was not yet added. This would become standardized on P-51D-15-NA production.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- On early P-51D's, the oil access door atop the nose cowling, was of the same size and design as that of the aftercoolant access door. The oil access door would not be enlarged until P-51D-20-NA production, when a dip stick was provided, requiring additional room to be accessed.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- On early P-51D's, the elevators were still covered in fabric, just as the rudder. By later P-51D production, the elevators were "metalized".<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- Unique to the P-51D-5-NA, a white, upward-facing recognition light was fixed to the spine of the aircraft, just behind the radio antenna. <o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- The design of the canopy plexiglas, as fitted to P-51D-5-NA's, was also entirely unique to just the D-5-NA production run, with the tallest portion of the canopy actually positioned behind the pilot's head. The canopy plexiglas would be re-designed for P-51D-10-NA production, with the tallest portion of the glass positioned well-forward, and would become the standard canopy design.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p> </o:p>
- Until P-51D-10-NA production, there was also not yet an external push-button release for opening the canopy externally, as would be installed near to the emergency canopy release handle.
<o:p> </o:p>
Both “Glengary Guy” and “The Comet” are un-finished at this time, but very near completion. 7-historic examples of the P-51D-5-NA will be covered, and matched to their unique and individual configurations.

20th FG "Glengary Guy"

Glengary_Guy_Exterior_Ground_1.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_Ground_2.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_Ground_4.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_Ground_5_small.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_In_Flight_2.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_In_Flight_1.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_In_Flight_3.jpg
 
P-51D-5-NA Interior

On to the interior details.
<o:p></o:p>
- The instrument panel, as clearly illustrated, was pure P-51B/C in design and layout. On P-51D-10-NA and later production, the instrument panel layout was re-designed, and the instruments were front mounted instead of rear mounted.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- The main electrical panel design within the P-51D-5-NA featured a 4th recognition light switch, for the white recognition light on the spine of the aircraft. This panel would be re-designed on P-51D-10-NA production and onwards, with the deletion of the upward facing white recognition light, and the layout of switches changed.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- The D-5-NA’s featured an earlier mixture control, like the P-51B’s and C’s, with positions at "Idle Cutoff," "Auto Lean," and "Auto Rich." This would be replaced with a single position mixture control and plate with positions at "Idle Cutoff," "Run," and "Emergency Full Rich" on P-51D-10-NA's and later models.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- On P-51D-10-NA's, the oxygen warning lamp, as installed on the instrument panel in the P-51D-5-NA, was made inoperative, and would later be completely removed. The oil gage service line connection, and the vacuum system adjustment knob, on the instrument panel, would also be removed with the instrument panel re-design on P-51D-10-NA production, with the vacuum system adjustment knob moving behind the instrument panel.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- An N-9 reflector gun sight was installed on P-51D-5-NA's, and would remain the standard production-installed sight until mid P-51D-20-NA production. A backup ring and bead gun sight was also provided, which would remain until mid P-51D-15-NA production.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- The throttle lever installed on all P-51D's which were manufactured with the N-9 gun sight, was the standard sphere-grip type. The throttle lever would change to a twist-handle, "bicycle grip" throttle lever with the introduction of the K-14 gun sight during P-51D-20-NA production.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- Early D-models, including the D-5-NA, only featured a carburetor air control lever at the back of the trim pedestal. Later aircraft would have a carburetor hot air control lever added next to the carb air control lever.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- On early D-models, the armor plate was positioned lower than that on later examples. On P-51D-20-NA production, and onwards, the armor plate was raised 2.25 inches. Until this time, the canopy was allowed to travel backwards, beyond the position of the armor plate. Due to the raised-position of the armor plate on P-51D-20-NA's and later models, the canopy was limited in travel.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- A manual primer pump was installed on the P-51D-5-NA, and would remain until P-51D-15-NA production, when an electrical primer was added.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- On P-51D-5-NA's, the seat installed was that of an early version of the Warren McArthur tubular-frame seat, as was commonly installed on P-51B's and C's before.<o:p></o:p>
<o:p></o:p>
- The P-51D-5-NA had an early-design spare bulbs locker, directly below the oxygen regulator, which was the same as was incorporated into the P-51A's, B's, and C's before it. By P-51D-20-NA production, this spare bulbs locker was removed, and a spare bulbs shelf was added to the inside of the instrument panel shroud.

WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_1.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_3.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_9.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_8.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_7.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_In_Flight_2.jpg



Through the illustrations from the original manuals, as well as period photos, here is a further demonstration of how things changed between the P-51D-5-NA and later P-51D's (they weren't all created equally!). : )

The P-51D-5-NA instrument panel (actually not fully correct in this illustration), and the later re-designed panel as seen on all other P-51D's.

Manual_Early_Panel.jpg


Manual_Late_Panel.jpg


The P-51D-5-NA main electrical panel layout, and the layout of the main electrical panel on all other P-51D's.

Manual_Early_Elect_Panel.jpg


Manual_Late_Elect_Panel.jpg


And some illustrations, demonstrating the oil gage servicing outlet, and the vacuum system adjustment knob, as only seen within the cockpit on the P-51D-5-NA.

Manual_Oil_Gage_Line.jpg


Manual_Adjustment_Knob.jpg
 
N-9 Reflector Gun Sight

As far as I know, this is the first time a fully-modeled N-9 reflector gun sight has ever been created for a Microsoft-based flight simulator platform.

Through some mad material and texture experiments, I was able to reproduce the reticle in collimated and true-"lit" form. The reticle itself is actually truly "translucent", and really glows, appearing as if projected by a light source, just as in real life.

Here are some screenshots showing the reticle under different conditions.

WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_In_Flight_1.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_In_Flight_3.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_In_Flight_4.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_In_Flight_5.jpg
 
That looks great.

As a side note, wasn't the Miles M.20 the first fighter, granted it was a non production aircraft, with a bubble canopy? I don't know if it was distortion free or not.

Also, are there still plans to bring a native FSX version of your P-51B/C to FSX? Is this the stepping stone to that? ;)

They look great, but that's being pathetically redundant on my part, as we already know full well the quality of your work. I was just flying one of your P-51's the other day, but there are hundreds if not thousands of those stories to be told in this forum.
I love reading your Mustang history lessons as well. Don't stop.
 
Thank you Sundog! About the Miles M.20, you may very well be correct!

The currently available Warbirdsim P-51B/C's for FSX are fully native as they stand right now, but they are quite a bit aged, and have been under the knife, on and off, for quite some time, for an eventual full-upgraded version. I can say that there was a signficant purchase made on my part, about a week ago, that will definitely help see this upgrading through to completion much faster. Also, as you might think, there is so much P-51B/C in the P-51D-5-NA cockpit, that a good portion of the cockpit of the P-51B/C can be upgraded by simply using what exists in the cockpit of the P-51D-5-NA. However, the challenging part comes down to items like the windscreen/canopy enclosure assemblies, and entirely different gear wells and wing-to-fuselage fillets. I can say that the future looks bright for high-back Mustangs in general - though that future is still quite a bit of ways away, with other aircraft on the bench as well.

I'm glad you like my story-telling! ; )
 
On another note, as some might question, this 'little project' has been in development for quite some time, dating back to early summer. With the lack of a dorsal fin fillet, and fabric elevators instead of metal examples, I decided to completely re-tool the exterior textures, so that there wasn't a 'patch-job', and everthing would flow together. It also gave me a chance to continue to experiment with material and texture configurations/settings, into what is seen in the screenshots.

Glengary_Guy_Exterior_Ground_3.jpg


Glengary_Guy_Exterior_Ground_1_small.jpg


As the technical order, or "T.O.", that was issued when the dorsal fin fillet was added into production D-models, stated that all P-51's operating without dorsal fin fillets had to have one of the kit fillets installed, by late '44 and into 1945 it would have been extremely rare to see a P-51D-5-NA operating without a dorsal fin fillet installed, most especially in England. At least one of the examples which will be covered in this product, will have one of the kit dorsal fin fillets installed, just as the famous photos of it show it to have. These early kit fillets, had a slight curve in the leading edge, where as the production/later fin fillets had a perfectly straight leading edge. They also both had a different construction configuration inside.

6n-j1-1.jpg


5856430122_0e027d5385_o.jpg


D-5_Real-1.jpg


4547028444_e5e2c1c265_o.jpg


ho-p5.jpg


c5-n.jpg


e2-a2.jpg
 
This little illustration, using the three canopy types as supplied in the new Tamiya P-51D kit, shows the three 'standard' canopy glazing types as seen on P-51D's during WWII (there were actually at least two other, less-standard types then these as well, originating on Dallas-produced Mustangs).

The bottom-most canopy design is what was used on, and only on, P-51D-5-NA production. The middle canopy design is of the re-designed type, as incorporated on P-51D-10-NA and later P-51D production, and became known as the "California" type. The upper-most canopy design is of the "Dallas" type, as seen on most very-late model P-51D's that came from the Dallas production line (though earlier Dallas-produced Mustangs sported canopies of the same design/form as the "California" type).

standard.jpg
 
WHEN?!?!?!?!? :wavey:

Definitely within the amount of days that one could count on a full supply of fingers and toes. ; )

I'm not too much of a fan of presenting these types of threads early, before product release, but I figured I should at least get some of this information un-loaded before too long. : )

BTW, if not looking at anything else on the aircraft, one of the easiest ways to know a P-51D-5-NA when you see it, is if the serial number on the tail starts with '413'.
 
Some more views of the P-51D-5-NA cockpit. This will be it for tonight, though I will try to provide some more screenshot updates in a few days.

WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_6.jpg


WBS_P-51D-5-NA_Cockpit_Ground_4.jpg
 
One of the best 3D modelling I've seen.Are you planning to go through all Mustang versions including P-51H, or even F-82?
And a little something: please add the brake lines, there are on the real a/c so...apart of the fidelity of the model, if you want to do a realistic walk around before flight, they have to be there:engel016:
 
We would love to do the whole series eventually, you never know.

There are many projects in the pipeline including Mustangs, but you are more likely to see something from the UK side of the pond as the next major project!
</SPAN>
John’s attention to detail on the Mustang is second to none.
Mr. Mustang as I think of him, is hard at work making the finishing touches to part of an incredible series of aircraft for Little Friends Part II and I for one can’t wait to see the finished article.</SPAN>

Best Wishes,</SPAN>
Albert
www.warbirdsim.com</SPAN>
 
Definitely within the amount of days that one could count on a full supply of fingers and toes. ; )

I'm not too much of a fan of presenting these types of threads early, before product release, but I figured I should at least get some of this information un-loaded before too long. : )

BTW, if not looking at anything else on the aircraft, one of the easiest ways to know a P-51D-5-NA when you see it, is if the serial number on the tail starts with '413'.

Thank you John and you know I will be one of the first to buy this gem! Never enough of your work on my PC. I hope to release the remainder of my VLR repaints once I'm settled into my new digs. This divroise thing is throwing me for a spin......

thank you for all your hard work......I am praying we'll see a late model corsair from you guys too.....:salute:
 
Great history lesson John! The only thing which I thought was missing is a picture from the original 43-12102

P51_312102.jpg


The models look stunning as usual. I absolutely love your paintwork and the incredible amount of historical correct details you always put in your models.

Cheers,
Huub
 
Back
Top