• There seems to be an uptick in Political comments in recent months. Those of us who are long time members of the site know that Political and Religious content has been banned for years. Nothing has changed. Please leave all political and religious comments out of the forums.

    If you recently joined the forums you were not presented with this restriction in the terms of service. This was due to a conversion error when we went from vBulletin to Xenforo. We have updated our terms of service to reflect these corrections.

    Please note any post refering to a politician will be considered political even if it is intended to be humor. Our experience is these topics have a way of dividing the forums and causing deep resentment among members. It is a poison to the community. We appreciate compliance with the rules.

    The Staff of SOH

  • Server side Maintenance is done. We still have an update to the forum software to run but that one will have to wait for a better time.

La Spezia project finally completed!

Rami

Administrator
Staff member
Stefano,

How are you? Finals began for my students today, and I found myself in a classroom while my students were studying with nothing to do. Since I had my laptop with me, I started working on another package Tobob sent me a little while ago to complete; La Spezia, Italy. After about four hours, I felt comfortable enough with it to post some pics, but since this is reasonably close to Fidenza, I'd like your opinion about whether this scenery is on the right track.

Thanks in advance,
 
Stefano,

How are you? Finals began for my students today, and I found myself in a classroom while my students were studying with nothing to do. Since I had my laptop with me, I started working on another package Tobob sent me a little while ago to complete; La Spezia, Italy. After about four hours, I felt comfortable enough with it to post some pics, but since this is reasonably close to Fidenza, I'd like your opinion about whether this scenery is on the right track.

Thanks in advance,

Hi Rami!

Doing well thank you, yourself? Just like me, you can't sit still with "oh, so many things to do in CFS2, so little time!!" Uhu?

La Spezia looks good, my friend. I'd like to do some input for you, because I can pinpoint the military Arsenal in the harbour. I think Yagdflieger can do it as well, he was there last year with me and Xavier!

When we visited the Military Naval Museum, there was a model display of the way the harbour looked in 1944. Both Xavier and I took pictures of it and both said: "Rami will jump with joy seeing this!". Although the picture is not great because the glass cover reflected the light, I'll send it over to you.

I will check also with Google maps to see how much of the military harbour is visible and let you know, in the meantime you could send me your layout file.

Cheers!
Stef
:ernae:
 
Reply...

Stefano,

I am well, though I had a meeting before the school board recently because some parents didn't like the content I was teaching. (The Banana wars, Sanford Dole and US economic interests Vs Hawaii, US occupation of Haiti, putting the Shah in power, Eisenhower sending the Marines into Lebanon, etc.) Because I was not espousing my own beliefs on the students and was well entrenched in the facts, the school board, the teacher's union, and the school principal backed me 100%.

Mom's also been reasonably stable in dialysis, so that's a plus. And, my eldest daughter is going to be five soon! Yikes, huh?

I am attaching a beta testing package here for you. I don't think you'll have problems with this, but you need the scenery for the layout to work properly. I included a couple of modified files I use that were given to me by Robert John at my request. Let me know if you can't find anything, or if something looks funny!
 
Stefano,

I am well, though I had a meeting before the school board recently because some parents didn't like the content I was teaching. (The Banana wars, Sanford Dole Vs Hawaii, US occupation of Haiti, putting the Shah in power, Eisenhower sending the Marines into Lebanon, etc.) Because I was not espousing my own beliefs on the students and was well entrenched in the facts, the school board, the teacher's union, and the school principal backed me 100%.

Mom's also been reasonably stable in dialysis, so that's a plus. And, my eldest daughter is going to be five soon! Yikes, huh?.......

Roger wilco, Andrew!

Good to read your mom is fairly well, as to start worrying about who's gonna be your daughter's date, well, that's life my friend! We say here it's a wheel that turns around and never stops....;)

Last year Jagd told me the other problem you had with the grades you gave to one of your students, this year they are breaking your ...... for your lesson topic. Oh, well...I am not missing my teaching days!!! Nowaday's parents here are exactly the same: their kids are absolute geniuses and real life cannot be taught to them, least their sensitive soul be offended!

There was a time here when any complaint from a teacher or low grades resulted directly in swift kicks from our dads in our rear ends, invariably. Mine still remembers them.....

I get back to you with La Spezia as soon as I upload my new Mauro's planes mod pack.

Cheers!
Stef
:ernae:
 
Andrew & Stef,

I installed the La Spezia scenery and found the following:

LC_laspevia_tb.bgl needs to be placed in a separate scenery layer further down the heirachy (same as Taranto scenery). The island will then show up correctly.

The two lighthouses were the only GSL objects I could get to show up in free flight. All the other objects are there when I look at the gob with GSLedit - very puzzling.

Cheers,
Kevin
 
Disregard the second part of my last - once I separated the scenery into 3 gobs everything showed up. It looks fantastic! :applause:
 
Reply...

LC_laspevia_tb.bgl needs to be placed in a separate scenery layer further down the heirachy (same as Taranto scenery). The island will then show up correctly.

Yes, that's true. My solution to that, because I have all of his scenery packages installed, is to have a common folder called "Tobob land and watermasks" for those files, and then have the "TB_xxxxx" folders separately.

The two lighthouses were the only GSL objects I could get to show up in free flight. All the other objects are there when I look at the gob with GSLedit - very puzzling.

Yes, as you correctly fixed. I correctly anticipated, because the layout box is about six miles in rectangle form, that it would be a multi-gob GSL file. Before using GSLedit, I ran it through Gob checker, which split the layout into three parts. I hadn't done that yet with the layout file because I wanted some input and feedback from Kelticheart, and now Jagdflieger, and if possible, Xavierb.
 
La Spezia

Rami,

KH gave me a wonderful tour of La Spezia last year on my visit with him and Xavier. By the way, while I haven't see Xavier here lately, he's a NATO historian at La Spezia and could probably also help. Sadly I lost his and all my other E-mail addresses just before Christmas so I can't help you in getting in touch with him.

Here is a photo I took of a model of the harbor at the La Spezia Navy Museum. It shows the bomb damage from allied bombing.
 
My little corner chirp...

....back when I was a young squid riding a greyhound (DD) we visited La Spazia and were moored right outside the old German U-Boat pens, which were built into the side of a mountain that seemed to come down to the sea and everything from there seemed to be straight up! They were just inside of a breakwater upon which remnants of AA batteries could still be descerned. The town was really hilly and that is why that diorama throws me off as it doesn't seem to depict the steepness of the hills. Maybe it is memory that is playing games.
 
Reply...

....back when I was a young squid riding a greyhound (DD) we visited La Spazia and were moored right outside the old German U-Boat pens, which were built into the side of a mountain that seemed to come down to the sea and everything from there seemed to be straight up! They were just inside of a breakwater upon which remnants of AA batteries could still be descerned. The town was really hilly and that is why that diorama throws me off as it doesn't seem to depict the steepness of the hills. Maybe it is memory that is playing games.

Fibber,

I looked on Google Earth, and found the evidence of a Sub Pen and breakwater that you described. Is this what you had in mind?
 
When SOH's members gang up.....

Hi Rami,

Jagd beat me to posting the Arsenale (military harbour) picture of the model showing how La Spezia docks looked on April 25, 1945, which is the official WWII armistice day in Italy. I hadn't looked at that picture in a while, now I realise it could be a little confusing, because it shows all the damage done to the harbour infrastructures by Allied bombings, but, with a little effort, main builidings, workshops and warehouses can still be made out.

I'll reply with attaching two great shots of the "Three Muskeeters"..... :icon_lol: visiting the Naval Museum, from left to right Xavier and Dave (1st picture) with behind them on display a "Maiale" (Hog), the WWII submarine attack, slow speed torpedo ridden by two sub operators. This was the ship used for the 1941 attack to Alexandria, Egypt, harbour. The second shot shows yours truly, Dave and Xavier in the museum entrance hall with Roman jars and anchor heads pulled from the sea bottom in front of La Spezia.

Perhaps, if we try matching the Arsenale model with Google Earth, or even Google maps at street level, we could find its exact location for CFS2. In answer to Jadg's problem of losing Xavier's e-mail I will send it to both of you via PM.

Cheers!
KH
:ernae:
 
Rami

that's how they looked., but the entrances of the pens were orientated towards the breakwater. I cannot accurately remember the distance to the pens from the breakwater though. I do remember reading (somewhere) of the experiences of pilots attacking these pens and how hard it was because of the way they were built in with the breakwater in front.
 
Reply...

Fibber,

I took a stab at making the breakwater much tighter, but I will not be able to post any pics until I return home.

Update: Fibber, how is this? I can make it even tighter if need be.
 
RAMI...

IIRC...in your first picture where the grey juts out nearest the jetty is appox where they were. I do remember my friend, our DD's Quartermaster and helmsman, (weird what the brain can remember!!!!) talking about the seamanship required to get a sub out / into those pens and that it was almost straight up for those hills. BTW there were several AA battery remnants that we saw on those hills. I did have pictures but after several moves and many years I doubt I still have them other than in my noggin! I will look though, always the possibility......
 
Reply...

IIRC...in your first picture where the grey juts out nearest the jetty is appox where they were. I do remember my friend, our DD's Quartermaster and helmsman, (weird what the brain can remember!!!!) talking about the seamanship required to get a sub out / into those pens and that it was almost straight up for those hills. BTW there were several AA battery remnants that we saw on those hills. I did have pictures but after several moves and many years I doubt I still have them other than in my noggin! I will look though, always the possibility......

Fibber,

Thanks for the feedback. I'll look through Pen32Win's coastal defense packages and find some appropriate AA positions. I do have plenty of AA stations already though, not to worry!
 
Does look good. I did smile, and then reminded myself that this is CFS2! It still amazes me what we can do to and with CFS2....

Great work fellas! :applause:

Rami, you're on a roll at the moment, so many good sceneries.


Shessi
 
I am not seeing anything different

Hi Rami!

I installed Tobob's scenery last night and flew over it taking off from Achim's Piacenza-San Damiano. La Spezia is just over the Appennini chain, due South/South East.

What am I supposed to see? Buildings and such are in the layout file, I'll see them in place today as soon as I start MB, but, as far as flattens, new coast lines, etc., I did not see any difference from the standard CFS2 with Rhumba's mesh and SdC's ETO coastlines/land texture on top of it.

I placed the flattens in \scenedb\world\scenery as per the enclosed intructions, while the rest is installed as any other scenery, yet at the same high priority level I placed Tobob's Bari and Taranto, which display splendidly.

Could you post a bare aerial view, sans objects, of Tobob's La Spezia from your pc, so that I can see what I am missing?

Thank you!
Stef
:ernae:
 
Reply...

Kelti,

The difference is in the islands before you reach the harbor. The first pic represents the scenery in place, with the harbor islands visible. The second pic is the way it looks with Sander's files, and why I asked for a fix. The harbor where the objects are placed really wasn't a problem, I was just being my typical anal-retentive self. :icon_lol:
 
Some ID for La Spezia harbour

Kelti,

The difference is in the islands before you reach the harbor. The first pic represents the scenery in place, with the harbor islands visible. The second pic is the way it looks with Sander's files, and why I asked for a fix. The harbor where the objects are placed really wasn't a problem, I was just being my typical anal-retentive self. :icon_lol:

And you are absolutely right, because a La Spezia scenery without the Isola di Palmaria would have not been realistic at all! :applause:

Unfortunately there's another detail that doesn't look too good, I'll explain below.

I cannot understand why I did not notice the small Palmaria Island disappearing from the screen without Tobob's files in place.... it's probably due to the fact that we passed from near-winter, monsoon-like (yet cold as hell!) rainy weather to over 90 F (33 C) degrees with 89% humidity in less than two weeks. I feel as if I had a boiled brain!
My help request came only out of fear of having misplaced Tobob's scenery, with all the mistakes I had made in the past! :isadizzy: Nevertheless, last night I had my usual fist fight with Mission Builder, which kept telling me a misterious "%s" object is missing from my database, everytime I loaded your layout in place. To tell the truth, I had this MB warning in the past with every layout for Achim's sceneries, but, since nothing vital seemed to be missing in each scenery, I kinda' ignored it.

Now I am really curious what library object this might be, have you got any idea from your vaste SOH librarian knowledge? ;)

About the layout, it already looks nice but I think that the civilian/commercial harbour difference from the military area should be more evident. Besides, I would not use Wolfi's forest patches in town, as all Liguria region towns are heavily settled with extremely thin flat areas where to build, since the Northern Appennini chain drops directly into the sea in many places. Between the Po Valley and Liguria there are peaks over 2,000 m (over than 6,000') high. To be more specific, 99% of Liguria looks like Ireland's tall cliff-ed Western shore and the Cliffs of Moher.

Therefore, forest patches are more proper on the steep hills looming over La Spezia and surroundings, sparse single trees would be much more realistic and I'll take care of it. I'll see also if I can mix Wolfi's Med buildings with something more akin to continental Europe because, as you saw yourself when you were here, this part of Italy looks considerably less Mediterranean than the rest of it. Much more like French Cote Azure than Naples, for example.

I did a little homework to help identify La Spezia harbour better, I hope I will not be arrested for spying like those Japanese secret agents at Pearl!

Attached below two Google maps:


  1. in the first I indicated the various areas, I hope the distinction between the commercial and the military harbours is clear. The dotted line indicates the heavily settled city limits: I would not place forest patches inside of it. Wooded areas are instead the light green patches, actually mountains, to the East and West of La Spezia.
  2. This is the "L" shaped Arsenale closeup, which matches the WWII model picture Jagd attached above. This was the main target for Allied bombings, as warships were moored here for resupply, repairs and such. Google's small "A" cloud indicates the location of the Naval Museum Xavier, Dave and I visited last year. The Musem building was once part of the Naval Military Academy. Dave and I drove around it last year on our way to visit medieval Portovenere, right in front of Palmaria Island mentioned above, I am sure he still remembers the high wall surrounding all the military area and drydock.

The CFS2 scenery so-so detail I mentioned above can be seen from the first map: it's the important Magra River that flows SouthEast on the Northern side of the mountains surrounding La Spezia, visible in the upper right corner. In CFS2 only the estuary can be seen and the river is almost missing. I don't know if it can be fixed in CFS2, but to someone like me, who spent a lot of his vacation time in these places, it really looks poor.

Hoping this will help, until our next ideas exchange

Cheers!
KH
:ernae:
 
Reply...

Stefano,

1) Regarding the missing objects, there are a couple of ways to narrow your search. First, observe how many times that message occurs; this will help you determine how many times the object(s) are being used in the scenery. Second, you can also open up the layout file and cross-reference the files in your objects_dp folder to determine quickly what you are missing.

If you need help at that point finding anything, let me know.

2) Regarding La Spezia, I'm going to tell you the exact same thing I told Dombral about Taranto. I am not adverse to ideas / modifications from others on this, especially considering that you have been there. Remember, I specifically sought out your opinion and it would be arrogant of me not to listen, don't you think?

If you believe that you can add more distinction between the military and civilian areas, including forests and whatnot, by all means, give it a try. I'd be very interested to see another person's ideas on this, in the meantime I'll pack my bags and head up to Trondheim.

I'll make sure to check with Morton upon getting there, though.
 
Back
Top