I would enthusiastically second Beans' comments, above! I likewise have both, and similarly, the CH jobbie collects dust in a corner nearby, while my Saitek works perfectly like the day it arrived, a long, long while ago.
There's also the matter of "spring noise" in the CH: I suffered through a lot of "sproing"-ing and "twang"-ing from the thing before my sweet Saitek arrived. Almost every time I pulled back on the yoke, the springs reminded me of their noisy presence. There's none of that in the Saitek.
I also find the programmable switches on the Saitek's throttle quadrant to be very useful, and thoughtfully positioned, and the entire yoke is nice and "beefy" -- it simply feels good in my (admittedly large) hands.
Overall, imho, the Saitek wins any comparison hands down.