USS Sable hit by U-boat!?

stoney

SOH-CM-2023
A friend sent this to me to day. It's the first I've heard of it:

"The U-boat was spotted for the first time by amateur scuba divers in late January and they had contacted the authorities. Archaeologists associated with Niagara University of and master divers from the U.S Coast Guard were mobilized on site to determine what it was, and they soon realized that they were dealing with a German submarine that sank during World War II.
A wreck recovery vessel of the Great Lakes Shipwreck Historical Society was mandated to refloat the ship and bring it back to Niagara Falls, where it must be restored before becoming a museum ship. The delicate recovery operation took nearly 30 hours to complete, but the submarine was finally brought down on the bank with relative ease.

The submarine was identified as the UX-791, a unique experimental German submarine, based on the U-1200 model, and known to have participated in the “Battle of the St. Lawrence”. It was reported missing in 1943 and was believed to have been sunk near the Canadian coast.
Professor Mark Carpenter, who leads the team of archaeologists, believes that the U-boat could have traveled up the St-Lawrence River, all the way to the Great Lakes, where it intended to disturb the American economy.
A report from the dated from February 1943 suggests, that the ship could have attacked and destroyed three cargo ships and two fishing vessels, even damaging the USS Sable (IX-81), an aircraft carrier of the U.S. navy that was used for training in the Great Lakes, before finally being sunk by anti-sub grenades launched by a Canadian frigate.
“We have known for a long time that the Nazis had sent some of their U-boats in the St-Lawrence River, but this is the first proof that they actually reached the Great Lakes,” Professor Carpenter told reporters. “This could explain the mysterious ship disappearances that took place in the region in 1943, and the reported “Battle of Niagara Falls” which had always been dismissed as a collective hallucination caused by fear.”
The restoration of the submarine could take more than two years, but once completed, the museum ship is expected to become one of the major tourist attractions of the region.
 
Right. Snopes said "As with all of World News Daily Report's content, the Nazi sub story was entirely fabricated."
 
One time long ago my mother was going through some papers of hers when she came upon some letters written to her by Dad when he was overseas in 3rd Army. One of the letters contained an article from a Nazi propaganda screed - complete with hand-drawn illustration - of a U-boat that had penetrated the St Lawrence and was busily engaged in an attack on merchant shipping. He must have found it in some town in southern Germany, or maybe in what was then Czechoslovakia. I can remember what he had written across the top - "They actually believe this stuff!" Can't believe the authors may have gulled someone into likewise believing this nonsense as reported actually happened. This is what happens when the Greatest Generation is now rapidly dying off and no one is around to correct the BS that is starting to surface - from the media and academia as well - about that conflict.

That submarine definitely looks Russian, and I'd bet there a better than even chance that's one of those derelict boats they have tied up around buoys at their sub bases that managed to slip its moorings and drifted ashore; those in the photo must be engaged in retrieving it.
 
That pic is the Russian November class SSN K-159 that sank while under tow some years ago. The only German U-boat that ever entered the Great Lakes was U-505, the one captured by Adm. Dan Gallery's task group during WWII and now on display at the Museum of Science & Industry in Chicago.
 
The big giveaway is that the St. Lawrence River and the Great Lakes (except for Lake Ontario, which is not the lake the Sable sailed on) are on opposite sides of Niagara Falls. There is no way a U-boat, or any other vessel, could make it past Niagara. And since the St. Lawrence Seaway hadn't been built yet, it's doubtful that any but the very smallest vessels, drawing much less water than a U-boat, could've made it even as far upriver as Lake Ontario in those days.

This is why American subs built in the Great Lakes region had to sail down the Mississippi to reach the sea.

Anyone who fell for this tale must be desperately deficient in their knowledge of geography!

 
Back
Top