Hornfischer is an excellant writer, my favorie is the Last Stand of the Tincan Sailors about the Battle off Samar. He seems to consider leadership as the most important ingrediant in winning a battle. Meanwhile, on Aug.8-aug9th, 1942 we have the Battle of Savo Island, the USN's most embarrasing defeats in WWII. Henderson Field was not able to operate aircraft until Aug, 18th and the first Marine ac landed two days later, Aug. 20 also saw the Battle of the Ilu river (actually fought on the banks of Alligator Creek.)