Ace, I think it's a matter of who is really the best pilot, in flightsim or real life.
The J2M Raiden was designed as a Japanese interceptor, not a dogfighter, A pilot by the name of Akamatsu was known for taking on P-51 Mustangs in his Raiden and shooting them down. He survived the war. Saburo Sakai shot down 60 British, Dutch, and American planes, the pilots were not the untrained boobs nor their planes junk, that history records. He was the better pilot, and after losing the sight in one eye shot down 4 more planes. He survived the war. Bong, McGuire, and MacDonald all were excellent pilots, the P-38 was not the greatest dogfighter, but served them well. The Finns had the highest kill-to-losses ration of any air force in Fokker D-XXIs and Brewster Buffalos, they were the better pilots. There were Soviet aces lying the Mig-3s. Gerhard Barkhorn insisted he and his wingman stay in the Bf-109 G while the rest of the squadron were in Fw-190Ds. They were one with their planes.
I fly a stock Zero with Eric Joiner's trainer skins, I just like that orange undersurface, I trade off between Morton and Lobo DeSilva's panel, and have Lawdog/Obios sound pack.I've shot down so many Hellcats and Corsair's in QC I got bored with it. I'm by no means an expert pilot but I am a dead shot and like Akamatsu I'm a maniac in the air, no matter how good you are, there's always a faster gun out there. Brown got the Red Baron right where he wanted him, goodbye Red Baron.
In online competitions I think two planes of comparable performance and armament is really going to hinge on who is the best pilot, even a great pilot in a plane of lesser performance is dangerous.
Good flying to you
TonyBones