Personally, the last release from AlphaSim that I was interested in and purchased was the Long-EZ. Since that time, for me, it has been a long list of yawners. I'm not a great fan of Helicopters. . .I love flying them, but I don't need one of every military type ever built. I was looking forward to another civilian type airplane after the Long-EZ, but the Gee Bee and the Cessna 170 weren't it. With that and now the announcement of this "Islander", for me, it's simply another in a long line of uninteresting airplanes. I don't really think the yawns show any lack of class, but rather just another way of saying "sorry, not interested". Now if we got into name calling or other rudeness that would be considered true bashing, that would show a lack of class.
The Islander may do very well, those who yawned simply find it uninteresting and not worth waiting for.