-
Please see the most recent updates in the "Where did the .com name go?" thread. Posts number 16 and 17.
Lockheed S-3 Viking - The Sequel Thread
- Thread starter jmbiii
- Start date
morpheusfz
Members +
Paint
MaddogK
Sim Junkie
Very nice, always good to see another Hoover being an old crew member of one. There was a feeling something was a bit off as I looked at all the pics in this thread tho, the crew scale seemed funny, I don't recall the rear windows being so big compared to the pilots size. Then while looking at real pics I found what I was looking for. Sorry, I don't mean for it to sound like criticizm but the model just feels 'weird' when I look at the ingame screenies. Just an observation.
View attachment 12324
View attachment 12324
delta_lima
Charter Member 2015
Obviously, continuous improvement where possible is good - but Dino, I had a good 45 min hop aboard v1 and had some great fun. Love the model, and Russ's and Antonio's paints are smashing.
I had what appeared to be some coding conflict on the lights - I couldn't turn on the beacons without also turning on the interior panel lights. Turning off the interiors also turned off the beacon/nav lights. Maybe it's just me.
Thanks to all who have worked on this - not usually a fan of late 80s/90s period aircraft, but this one is stunning exception in my hangar.
cheers,
dl
I had what appeared to be some coding conflict on the lights - I couldn't turn on the beacons without also turning on the interior panel lights. Turning off the interiors also turned off the beacon/nav lights. Maybe it's just me.
Thanks to all who have worked on this - not usually a fan of late 80s/90s period aircraft, but this one is stunning exception in my hangar.
cheers,
dl
Dino Cattaneo
Charter Member
@All (& delta_lima)
There seems to be a bug in the light system indeed - I will double check that.
@MaddogK
I believe I got the whole airframe dimensions wrong (a little oversized), while the crew figures are slightly too thin/small... this is probably the reason why the model may look weird to a trained eye. Unfortunately there is nothing I can do about that at this point.
As I said, I will leave things as they are for a week or two to collect some feedback and then release an update.
There seems to be a bug in the light system indeed - I will double check that.
@MaddogK
I believe I got the whole airframe dimensions wrong (a little oversized), while the crew figures are slightly too thin/small... this is probably the reason why the model may look weird to a trained eye. Unfortunately there is nothing I can do about that at this point.
As I said, I will leave things as they are for a week or two to collect some feedback and then release an update.
seawing
Charter Member
Hi Dino!
Again a great release of a great aircraft! Thank you so much for it!!
As of feedback, I would like to rise a few points:
- most important (to me personally, anyways) are the torpedos. I do fully understand that TACPACK cannot at this time handle them other than put them on the aircrfat. Therefor I would like to suggest to have them simply jettisonable, like the tanks. This way one would be able to put them on and drop them again to "simulate" a torpedo launch. Anyway, the weight and the model of the torpedo could be removed by the selective jettison function of TACPACK. I think it would really be worth to have a function like this, since the S-3 is originally a sub hunter and the torpedo is the main weapon system.
- secondly, I see the light switches move in the VC overhead, but I cannot touch them. Is that intentional? Only the key commands make them move. Also, when I touch the turn knobs for the internal lighting of the cockpit, I discovered that the Nav lights also switch off. If I key-command the internal lights off (SHFT-L) the Nav lights stay on.
- the roll rate of the aircraft seems very low to me compared to what I saw the real S-3 do over NAS North Island. I put the effectivness value for the ailerons to 5.0 and it rolls much more like what I saw the real thing do.
- the landing light, although a work around if I understood you correctly, is somewhat misaligned with the light in the model. It should be slightly higher and further to the left (in direction of flight)
- from what I can see in pictures of the real aircrfat the lower gear doors should be closed a little further (at least with hydraulics on the aircraft) and the bomb bay doors be opened a little further (~90°) than they are in the model right now
- the wing fold sequence is to fast compared with video of the real aircraft, as is the tail fold, although I don't know whether the latter can actually be changed in speed for the water rudder function.
So, that is it for the moment! Sorry, but you asked for some feedback ... ;-)
Best regards,
Seawing
Again a great release of a great aircraft! Thank you so much for it!!
As of feedback, I would like to rise a few points:
- most important (to me personally, anyways) are the torpedos. I do fully understand that TACPACK cannot at this time handle them other than put them on the aircrfat. Therefor I would like to suggest to have them simply jettisonable, like the tanks. This way one would be able to put them on and drop them again to "simulate" a torpedo launch. Anyway, the weight and the model of the torpedo could be removed by the selective jettison function of TACPACK. I think it would really be worth to have a function like this, since the S-3 is originally a sub hunter and the torpedo is the main weapon system.
- secondly, I see the light switches move in the VC overhead, but I cannot touch them. Is that intentional? Only the key commands make them move. Also, when I touch the turn knobs for the internal lighting of the cockpit, I discovered that the Nav lights also switch off. If I key-command the internal lights off (SHFT-L) the Nav lights stay on.
- the roll rate of the aircraft seems very low to me compared to what I saw the real S-3 do over NAS North Island. I put the effectivness value for the ailerons to 5.0 and it rolls much more like what I saw the real thing do.
- the landing light, although a work around if I understood you correctly, is somewhat misaligned with the light in the model. It should be slightly higher and further to the left (in direction of flight)
- from what I can see in pictures of the real aircrfat the lower gear doors should be closed a little further (at least with hydraulics on the aircraft) and the bomb bay doors be opened a little further (~90°) than they are in the model right now
- the wing fold sequence is to fast compared with video of the real aircraft, as is the tail fold, although I don't know whether the latter can actually be changed in speed for the water rudder function.
So, that is it for the moment! Sorry, but you asked for some feedback ... ;-)
Best regards,
Seawing
Dino Cattaneo
Charter Member
Well, I always ask for feedback - and it always welcome. It is the only way to understand where you can improve.
...to be honest, I would have preferred to get more feedback from version 0.99 - most of the issues for which I received feedback were addressed... But in Italy we say "better late than never", and I expected that some people would have skipped v0.99...anyway, I'll tray to update the S-3 when possible...
- Torpedoes, I have to confess I do not know how to create a bespoke, jettisonable object which can be freely used in single player and in multiplayer. Tacpack can be used to get rid of the weight, but to jettison the object it must be a Tacpack object.
- As per my previous message, there is still a bug in the light system - but you should be able to click the switches in v1.00.
- Roll rate - I will double check the flight manual (I do not think I had found clear indications). It would be an easy change anyway.
- Landing light, as well as every .fx effect, may have misplacement errors. It seems aligned on my setup, but I will double check.
- I will check again the doors opening against actual photographs
- Wing fold sequence speed has been already pointed out previously in this thread by Russ (and also noted on V0.99 - my apologies once again for having skipped this!). Afaik, rudder water deployment speed cannot be changed.
Thanks!
Dino
...to be honest, I would have preferred to get more feedback from version 0.99 - most of the issues for which I received feedback were addressed... But in Italy we say "better late than never", and I expected that some people would have skipped v0.99...anyway, I'll tray to update the S-3 when possible...
- Torpedoes, I have to confess I do not know how to create a bespoke, jettisonable object which can be freely used in single player and in multiplayer. Tacpack can be used to get rid of the weight, but to jettison the object it must be a Tacpack object.
- As per my previous message, there is still a bug in the light system - but you should be able to click the switches in v1.00.
- Roll rate - I will double check the flight manual (I do not think I had found clear indications). It would be an easy change anyway.
- Landing light, as well as every .fx effect, may have misplacement errors. It seems aligned on my setup, but I will double check.
- I will check again the doors opening against actual photographs
- Wing fold sequence speed has been already pointed out previously in this thread by Russ (and also noted on V0.99 - my apologies once again for having skipped this!). Afaik, rudder water deployment speed cannot be changed.
Thanks!
Dino
delta_lima
Charter Member 2015
Regarding the lights, I can switch them on/off, but what they do seems a bit wonky (as per my earlier post of the beacon and instrument lights being linked).
As with some models (the Flying Stations Bucc, for example) sometimes where you're zoomed at determines whether or not switch can be thrown. Usually cured by zooming in. So switches do seem to work, at least for me ... hope the actual light code logic can get sorted.
Spent a couple of hours doing some FCLP and carrier work last night ... man, is this a fun, stable, and beautiful model to fly. Inclined as I am to anything SIGINT, ELINT and or reconnaissance, I have to say even the ES-3A Shadow, with the antennae farm top and bottom, is a lovely aircraft ...
Well done Dino, Russ, Antonio, and all other participants. Definitely got Viking fever ...
As with some models (the Flying Stations Bucc, for example) sometimes where you're zoomed at determines whether or not switch can be thrown. Usually cured by zooming in. So switches do seem to work, at least for me ... hope the actual light code logic can get sorted.
Spent a couple of hours doing some FCLP and carrier work last night ... man, is this a fun, stable, and beautiful model to fly. Inclined as I am to anything SIGINT, ELINT and or reconnaissance, I have to say even the ES-3A Shadow, with the antennae farm top and bottom, is a lovely aircraft ...
Well done Dino, Russ, Antonio, and all other participants. Definitely got Viking fever ...
seawing
Charter Member
Hello Dino,
well, ok, concerning the torpedos, is there a way you could make the single torpedos removable? When I use your TACPACK stores management "panel" I can only put them all on or remove them all. Could you - as a kind of a work around to the discussed problem - change the management panel so that one could add and remove the torpedos one by one?
I will check the light switches again tomorrow and see how I could "grab" them.
Concerning the doors, I found, for instance, these pictures:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a3/Lockheed_S-3_Viking.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c1/Viking_S-3B.jpg
http://www.cybermodeler.com/aircraft/s-3/images/s-3dm-sh011.jpg
http://www.cybermodeler.com/aircraft/s-3/s-3_03.shtml
http://www.cybermodeler.com/aircraft/s-3/images/s-3b_right_gearwell2.jpg
http://www.skytamer.com/samples/Lockheed_S-3B_Viking_BuNo_159766_USS_Midway_Museum_John_Shupek.jpg
From these pictures, it appears that the mentioned doors hang down somewhat with no hydraulic power compared to their "on-power" condition.
Thanks again for all your time and effort into this and all your other planes!!
Best regards,
Markus
well, ok, concerning the torpedos, is there a way you could make the single torpedos removable? When I use your TACPACK stores management "panel" I can only put them all on or remove them all. Could you - as a kind of a work around to the discussed problem - change the management panel so that one could add and remove the torpedos one by one?
I will check the light switches again tomorrow and see how I could "grab" them.
Concerning the doors, I found, for instance, these pictures:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a3/Lockheed_S-3_Viking.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c1/Viking_S-3B.jpg
http://www.cybermodeler.com/aircraft/s-3/images/s-3dm-sh011.jpg
http://www.cybermodeler.com/aircraft/s-3/s-3_03.shtml
http://www.cybermodeler.com/aircraft/s-3/images/s-3b_right_gearwell2.jpg
http://www.skytamer.com/samples/Lockheed_S-3B_Viking_BuNo_159766_USS_Midway_Museum_John_Shupek.jpg
From these pictures, it appears that the mentioned doors hang down somewhat with no hydraulic power compared to their "on-power" condition.
Thanks again for all your time and effort into this and all your other planes!!
Best regards,
Markus
Dino Cattaneo
Charter Member
@Seawing - thanks... but rest assured I already downloaded (and went through) hunderds of pictures (including walkaround sent by fans)... In general, in absence of detailed drawings and specs, it is always possible that there are mistakes.
I will try to improve the model in the next round.
I will try to improve the model in the next round.
dhazelgrove
Charter Member
I believe that the word should be "refine", rather than "improve".
The model is already exceptional.
Dave
Dino Cattaneo
Charter Member
Thanks for the appreciation.
By the way, extending the project to cover ES-3 and US-3 has been considered and it is not ruled out for the future.
By the way, extending the project to cover ES-3 and US-3 has been considered and it is not ruled out for the future.
wombat666
Administrator
Dutcheeseblend
Blenderer
About the coupling between Nav and Instrument lights, I believe they are coupled by FSX itself. In the modeldef.xml, the animation code for the instrument lights gives both a command to toggle the instrument lights, and the nav lights. I don't know if this is the issue here, but that was what I encountered during my Fokker development. I solved it by creating a custom animation code that removes the nav lights toggle from the instrument lights.
The Viking is beautiful by the way. I've been flying Dino's bird for a few times, but I'm too busy with my own project and real life issues. So sorry for having no feedback
Keep up the good work!
The Viking is beautiful by the way. I've been flying Dino's bird for a few times, but I'm too busy with my own project and real life issues. So sorry for having no feedback
Keep up the good work!
skyhawka4m
Charter Member
Sundog
SOH-CM-2026
delta_lima
Charter Member 2015
Awesome ... would bring this old antenna-head much joy.
Meanwhile - thanks for the explanation, DCB - hope that can enable Dino to sort the lights. Not that if not fixed, it'd be the end of the world; it's just nice to extinguish the interior cockpit lights, formation lights, and nav/beacon lights individually of each other. But even if the lights was an "all or nothing" proposition, this bird is already outstanding.
thanks!
dl
golakers
Charter Member
Just almost finished my first repaint for Dino's magnificent Viking. "Almost", because the wolf on the tail is still copied from a low-res jpeg. Since I am a graphic-designer, I usually go the professional route of producing the tail graphics in vectors so I can scale them at will. Before that last step, I'd like to get some feedback on this one.
This is the CAG bird of VS-35 Blue Wolves, BuNo. 160577 NK700, WestPac cruise 1996, CVW-14 aboard USS Carl Vinson.
I have allready done both F-14D CAGs of VF-11 and VF-31 with rainbow tails, so these should fit nicely together. I'll do a low-viz Viking from the same year, right after i nail this one.
This is the CAG bird of VS-35 Blue Wolves, BuNo. 160577 NK700, WestPac cruise 1996, CVW-14 aboard USS Carl Vinson.
I have allready done both F-14D CAGs of VF-11 and VF-31 with rainbow tails, so these should fit nicely together. I'll do a low-viz Viking from the same year, right after i nail this one.
