Back in the day...before the great forum crash of 2008....there was great talk from the realists of putting a fan in front of you, throwing frozen peas into it to simulate bullets, putting castor oil on your face as well as a healthy dose for that oft seen effect of ingesting it from the exhaust or having the wife stand behind you and hit you in the head with a pan when you crash. There have been many of us that have decried those who fly OFF less than realistic, but always stressed the first importance of enjoying it. If using full aids and no cockpit and tight spread, etc makes you happy, then good for you. WM's 'R' rating helps keep things in perspective in this global world of the forum.
I have flown a number of light aircraft and can tell you, that the planes in OFF have good light airplane sensations, so they feel 'right' to me. I haven't flown a WWI type airframe (WF2 has and she likes the FM's) but if the dev team is happy with it, they should keep it as is. Otherwise, they enter Oleg's dance of death. Pilot reports from WWI can't be taken as gospel either esp. with the differences in mfg, storage, fuel, upkeep, etc. that even two planes of the same make and model flew differently. Remember this was the dawn of aviation. But, there is one computer limitation that does bear agreement with ZZ and that's visibility. The computer is limited in long range depiction of targets, air and ground, so you can't get 100% realism. The aids like tac and labels will compensate for that otherwise you will pass by much activity that you would've normally seen IRL. So, it's a compromise. That being said, I noticed after flying OFF for a while, that my skills in spotting aircraft, etc. did improve just as in real life. The immersion of OFF is such that you do start off as a rookie and your skills will develope and improve just as they would in real life if you lived long enough. You'll learn to tell whether those far off dots are a low flying formation or houses or bridges. Then you get the excitement of closing with them til you can discern whether they're friendly or enemy. In P2, I flew with no aids except to use labels to find the right railyard or armybase to attack. Now, I use labels and the tac display, sparingly and mostly to find out where the devil my formation went, because my frame rates are still low enough that I can't go solely by eyeball. And anyone who's been here a while, knows I like to use full realism.