Not FSX or XPlane, but here's a rather informative animation combined with actual ATC communications of flight 1549's bird impact and ditch. I think the 3D animation gives a good perspective of the minimal number of options they had at the altitude of bird impact.
http://www.exosphere3d.com/pubwww/pages/project_gallery/cactus_1549_hudson_river.html
http://www.exosphere3d.com/pubwww/pages/project_gallery/cactus_1549_hudson_river.html